Friday, January 24, 2014

Christian Anarchism: Anti-Empire Voices

The Prophets: Anti-Empire Voices
Ellul describes the role of the biblical prophet as “a politically very odd phenomenon” and “a counterforce”. While the kings dabble in militarism and empire-building, the voice of God speaks through the prophets, declaring God's anger at injustice and calling the people back to the deuteronomic way of life.

The prophets have a slightly higher profile in Christian Anarchist theology, perhaps because they are more clearly opposed to the rulers and systems of the time. The Ploughshares movement are Christian Anarchist activists who perform prophetic action in the vein of Ezekiel and others.1 Ploughshares protests usually involve breaking and entering a military base, hammering on, and pouring blood over, weapons or weapon carriers. Their name is taken from the prophecy of Isaiah 2:4 and Micah 4:3 to “Beat their swords into ploughshares and their spears into pruning hooks”.

There is scope to develop a theology of anarchy from Isaiah, as evidenced by Walter Brueggemann's sermon to Mars Hill Bible Church, Michigan in 2008 entitled “Isaiah and the Mission of the Church.”2 Brueggemann connects the political situation in the USA with both the “failed urban economy”3 of Jerusalem and the city of Babylon. “Chapter 46 says take on the power of the Empire. Challenge the gods of military consumerism. Do not trust them, do not serve them, do not obey them. Be a Jew. Be a person of faith.”4 He also connects chapter 52 verse 11's “depart” with the 'calling out' theme that resonates from Genesis to Revelation,5 stating: “Depart. Depart emotionally, depart psychologically, depart liturgically, depart economically. Organise your life around your faith and not according to the mantras of military consumerism.”6 This attitude of resistance, the call to leave systems of oppression and the desire to create a new, free society resonate strongly within anarchism.


The apocalypse of Daniel, like John's Revelation, represents imperial systems as beasts. Claiborne and Haw state: “The images of the beasts remind us that these creatures have mutated far from what God intended... systems of imperial power that had become so corrupt... they no longer reflected God's image or goodness.”7 In the face of these unnatural monsters, salvation comes in the form of 'one like a son of man'8 -human, adama9, of the earth10. This pretype of Christ appears juxtaposed to the empires of the world and glorified in the presence of God. For a captive people sitting out the rise and fall of evil power structures around them there is the hope of one who will come who is not of the bestial empires, but who represents reconnection with the earth and with God.

The story of the Hebrew Scriptures is a cycle of people being called out and set free from oppressive empires. In the wilderness, away from the centres of power, people meet with God and are given a mandate to live differently- to live free. This alternative lifestyle is the restoration of creation: After the fall comes the hope of a return to Eden; after Babylon comes the yearning to return home. For Christian Anarchists this is a significant point. In light of this reading of the Hebrew Scriptures anarchism is not a radical reinterpretation of the old law by Jesus. Rather, anarchism is the very heart of God, and the perfect state of a fully realised human society.

The Hebrew Scriptures can also be read as protest works. Whether in creation myth, law code or court history, the Hebrew Scriptures subvert the normative writing conventions to present works which take an oppositional approach to political power. Not only a work of protest, the Hebrew Scriptures also present a fully developed constitution for a ruler-less society, with a level of freedom and bias to the oppressed that even the most liberal administration today could aspire to.

The Hebrew Scriptures end with a yearning for political liberation and a chance to become the unique people of God once more.
1Ezekiel, Jeremiah, Isaiah 20:1-6, 2 Kings 13:15-19, 1 Kings 11:30-40
2Walter Brueggemann. “Isaiah and the Mission of the Church.” (Sermon delivered at Mars Hill Bible Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 20/07/2008). Mp3 audio file from http://marshill.org/teaching/ (accessed 22/9/08)
3Walter Brueggemann. “Isaiah and the Mission of the Church.” (Sermon delivered at Mars Hill Bible Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 20/07/2008). Mp3 audio file from http://marshill.org/teaching/ (accessed 22/9/08) 2 minutes 50 seconds
4Walter Brueggemann. “Isaiah and the Mission of the Church.” (Sermon delivered at Mars Hill Bible Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 20/07/2008). Mp3 audio file from http://marshill.org/teaching/ (accessed 22/9/08) 9 minutes 30 seconds
5Genesis 12:1 to Revelation 18:4
6Walter Brueggemann. “Isaiah and the Mission of the Church.” (Sermon delivered at Mars Hill Bible Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 20/07/2008). Mp3 audio file from http://marshill.org/teaching/ (accessed 22/9/08) 13 minutes 17 seconds
7Shane Claiborne and Chris Haw. Jesus for President: Politics for Ordinary Radicals.
Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan, 2008. Pg. 43
8Daniel 7:13 (NIV)
9אדם

10אדמה

No comments: